Why Fish Don't Exist
A tidy category can hide a dangerous assumption.
Big Idea
Miller’s investigation questions the need to impose fixed order on life, especially when certainty about categories becomes certainty about human worth.
The Appeal of Order
Jordan’s taxonomic work initially offers Miller an image of persistence in a chaotic world.
Rebuilding after Disaster
The shattered specimen collection becomes a story about continuing when a carefully built system breaks.
Reconsidering the Hero
Miller’s research complicates her initial admiration by examining the harms associated with Jordan’s beliefs.
Categories Have Limits
The title challenges fish as one complete evolutionary group, not the existence of aquatic animals.
More Than a Ladder
The narrative resists arranging living beings or people into a simple hierarchy of worth.
Khizooo Take
When a classification looks natural, ask what it groups together, what it excludes, and what happens when someone treats it as a ranking.
Remember
A useful category is not a measure of a person’s worth.